|
Wednesday, 7 October 2026
St Matthew 7: 17-18 In the same way, every good tree bears good fruit, but the bad tree bears bad fruit. A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a bad tree bear good fruit. St John 18: 36 Jesus answered, ‘My kingdom is not from this world. If my kingdom were from this world, my followers would be fighting to keep me from being handed over to the Jews. But as it is, my kingdom is not from here.’ Reflection One of the most powerful, and moving, objections to faith in God is the existence of suffering. Why would an all-powerful benevolent God allow children to die of cancer. Such questions have troubled believers throughout the ages. The Cathars’ answer was to adopt a dualist position meaning they believed there were two gods – the good God of heaven and the evil god of this age (see 2 Cor 4:4). People’s (good) spirits were trapped in (bad) bodies in an endless cycle of reincarnation. Only through living simply, rejecting the wealth and power of the world, and receiving the Cathar sacrament of the Consolamentum could one be freed. The ritual was seen as a way of separating from the world and the Evil One who controlled it. They believed that God could not bear bad fruit and that Jesus’ words about his Kingdom not being of this world were clues from Scripture suggesting a division between good and bad, light and dark, spirit and flesh. After receiving the Consolamentum the Cathar perfects were required to eat only vegetables and fish, to be celibate and to dedicate themselves to an itinerant ministry of preaching. Not all Cathars became perfects in life, though one aspired to receive the Consolamentum before death. The simplicity of Cathar lifestyles stood in stark contrast to the wealth of Church dignitaries and gave credence to their message. They were known simply as “good Christians” which rather implies a contrast with the Church of their age. There are no easy answers to questions about evil and suffering and one can see how it is tempting to take a dualistic position. Instead, we are invited to accept that, in the Incarnation, God’s own self became flesh recognising it as good. We wrestle with the painful mystery of suffering navigated only by the horror of the Cross. Instead of separation from humanity’s messiness, God – in Christ – joined our pain and suffering and offers the hope of eventual redemption. Prayer Console us O God, when confronted with suffering and pain; help us to sit with those who suffer offering not answers but love, not surety but hope, not our own efforts but grace, that, as we comprehend the violence of the Cross, we find healing and peace. Amen.
|