|
Thursday 1st October Heresy and Violence
The Podestà or Rector has the authority to oblige all heretics that he may have in his power, without breaking limbs or endangering their lives, to confess their errors and to accuse other heretics whom they may know, as true assassins of souls and thieves of the Sacraments of God and of the Christian faith, and their worldly goods, and believers in their doctrines, those who receive them and defend them, just as robbers and thieves of temporal goods are obliged to accuse their accomplices and confess the evil that they have done. Ad extirpanda Pope Innocent IV, 1252 Reflection
The medieval Church wanted to use all the tools at its disposal in order to find, correct, and – where necessary – punish heretics. Ancient Roman law was very squeamish about circumstantial evidence and so torture was often used to secure confessions. The Church wanted to be sure of the evidence it gathered and so Pope Innocent IV allowed violence “without breaking their limbs or endangering their lives” to secure confessions and denunciations. (Though by 1677 it was clarified that torture of a cleric could only be supervised by an ecclesiastical judge not a lay one!). Torture was a widely practiced civil process adopted by the Church. The concern about heresy is clear from our papal bull – heretics were “assassins and thieves”. After othering them and making them different to the good people who would read the Bull, it is possible to see them as unworthy of respect and kindness but worthy of violence. Nowadays, of course, torture is illegal in most jurisdictions, hidden where it does take place, and seen as unreliable as an evidence gathering technique; the tortured will say anything to stop the pain. Yet, when the need arises, even our great democracies have allowed torture; Guantanamo Bay, conveniently beyond the reach of American jurisprudence, became a centre for torture in the so-called war on terror. The greatest miscarriages of justice in the UK seem to have originated from practices akin to torture whilst suspects were in police custody – long before the days of videoed interviews. I did not select a Biblical reading for today; there’s no Biblical prohibition against violence or torture; some passages seek to limit violence, others to turn the other cheek, yet others allow violence. Pope Innocent and his advisors were as steeped in the Bible as we are – probably more so. A salient reminder that our new ideologies, and heresies, can as easily be justified by Scripture as the old ones were. Prayer Teach us kindness, Good Lord, that we might learn to listen to others with respect, disagree well, and find common ground, that our systems and laws will be free from violence and hatred, and our ideologies and beliefs will enhance life in all its fullness. Amen.
|