Reflection
Calling the Roll After an Engagement, Crimea (The Roll Call) by Elizabeth Thompson, who, after marriage, was known as Lady Butler (1874),
This painting went on show at the Royal Academy in summer, 1874, becoming instantly famous. A policeman had to control the crowds. Queen Victoria and Prince Albert bought it for the Royal Collection. It measures over 3 feet by 6, its predominance of greys, browns and blacks contrasting with splashes of red from flags and uniforms.
Thompson was a Roman Catholic who started with religious subjects before concentrating on war. She wrote in her autobiography: “I never painted for the glory of war, but to portray its pathos and heroism.” Her context was the height of empire, and her art fed upon and into many of empire’s assumptions and preoccupations.
Her art also did something more unusual in her day. By constructing The Roll Call as this long line of soldiers and by turning the mounted officer away from us, she draws us in to everyone rather than highlighting any one character or emphasising a leader. Looking closer, we see the aftermath of battle in the mass of men and details; bandaged hands and heads, a man collapsed, weary faces, a boot being tied, a man drinking water. Names are being called to see who still lives and who is missing. The air is filled with birds circling the battlefield. We imagine the carnage hidden behind these men.
War is the background to plenty in our Bibles. The story of David and Bathsheba begins: “In the spring, at the time when kings go off to war, David sent Joab out with the king’s men and the whole Israelite army. They destroyed the Ammonites and besieged Rabbah” (2 Samuel 11: 1). There can be a season for war, time when weather and circumstance suggest victory is more likely and advantage can be taken. But every battle has names; real places, real people. We remember only some of both. I look at Lady Butler’s line of soldiers in the snow, and wonder at the price paid by so many when nations make war.
Prayer
God of the nations,
you call us to be shapers of a future
in which justice is done and the fighting stops.
Our Bibles end with a vision of trees
whose fruits are for the healing of the nations.
But our story is still one of war.
I pray for everyone caught up in war’s calamity,
paying part of the price,
carrying the cost in body and memory,
heart and soul. Amen.